Can You Cook Fish on Cast Iron? (Things to Know Before Starting)

Table of contents

If you’ve ever wondered whether or not you can cook fish on cast iron, we have good news for you: the answer is yes!

But before you get started, there are a few things to know about cooking fish on cast iron that will make your experience even more enjoyable.

Key takeaways

Delicate fish should be avoided when cooking on cast iron due to the rough surface that can cause sticking.
Proper seasoning and keeping the cast iron dry are crucial for maintaining the skillet’s quality and preventing rust.
Storing food in a cast-iron pan should be avoided to prevent rusting, metallic taste, and potential health hazards.
Pan-searing fish on a cast-iron skillet can result in a crispy outer crust and prevent sticking when using medium-high heat and practicing patience.
To prevent fish from sticking, choose firm fish with skin, cook it skin-side down, ensure sufficient cooking time before flipping, and baste the fish to avoid drying out and sticking.

Can you cook fish on a cast iron?

you can cook fish on a cast iron skillet.

Cast iron is an ideal cookware for fish because it provides even heat distribution and excellent heat retention.

The skillet’s ability to get very hot allows for a good sear on the fish, resulting in a crispy exterior while maintaining the moistness of the fish.

Also, the natural non-stick properties of a well-seasoned cast iron skillet help prevent the fish from sticking during the cooking process.

How do you cook fish on cast iron?

One of the easiest and tastiest ways to cook fish in a cast iron skillet is to pan-roast it.

First, you need to dry your fish fillet well. This is going to help keep it from burning and help keep it from sticking as well.
Next, salt and pepper on both sides of your fillet.
Put your fillet’s skin side down in your cast iron skillet over high heat, you need one that is either non-stick or that has been well seasoned.
Allow your fish to cook on high for a few minutes, then switch to medium heat and allow your fish to cook on one side for about 2 to 3 minutes.
Flip your fish very carefully to the other side.
Add butter and any seasoning you want to the pan.
Use the butter to baste the fish until it is as golden as you want or until it is cooked all the way through. For normal-thickness fish, this will be about 90 seconds. If you have a thicker fillet it may take a bit longer.

What are the benefits of cooking fish on cast iron?

If you’re wondering what the benefits of cooking fish on cast iron are, you’re in luck. Cooking on cast iron is easier than many people think, and it can add extra flavor to your food.

In this section, we’ll cover why cooking with cast iron pans can be so beneficial and how they work!

Cooking anything on a cast iron allows for even cooking

There are a few reasons why cooking fish on cast iron is the best. First and foremost, cast iron pans are heavy and stay hot.

Heat is evenly distributed throughout the pan, so you don’t get hot spots or cold spots where food doesn’t cook properly. This is why they can help cook food evenly.

This prevents overcooking or undercooking certain areas of the fish, which can cause tough, dry spots and make it difficult to enjoy the full flavor of the fish.

This is especially helpful when cooking fish and meat that requires being cooked on both sides. Just flip your fish over and it’ll turn out great.

Cast irons are durable and can last a long time

Cast iron is durable and can last for generations, which makes it an excellent choice for making long-lasting kitchen staples.

Durability is important when cooking with cast iron because it can last for a long time, even with regular use.

Cast iron cookware is also ideal for high-heat cooking and is suitable for a variety of dishes that might include acidic ingredients.

Some people would claim that cast iron can last forever as long as you properly clean it when it’s dirty and maintain it well.

Cast irons can be non-stick as long as you season them

Seasoning cast iron pans is easy and the process will help create a non-stick surface.

Seasoning is simply oiling your pan with vegetable oil, heating it before cooking in it, and then letting it cool down while still on the stovetop before putting it away.

A non-stick surface prevents the food from sticking and burning, making it more difficult to clean.

Seasoning creates an easy-release film that minimizes sticking when cooking in your cast iron cookware.

Cooking with cast iron can add extra iron to your diet

Iron is an essential mineral that helps to carry oxygen throughout the body. It’s also critical for energy production and red blood cell formation.

Iron plays an important role in healthy blood production, cognitive function, and energy levels.

Iron deficiency can lead to anemia, a condition characterized by fatigue and weakness due to low levels of iron in the blood. Iron deficiency can also cause headaches, dizziness, hair loss, or brittle nails.

When cooking with cast iron pots or pans, you’re adding extra iron to your diet!

Cast iron cooking is said to enhance the flavor of food

When you cook on cast iron, the high heat of the pan helps caramelize the meat, which adds flavor.

Cooking fish on a cast iron skillet enhances flavor by creating a crispy outer crust. The flavors of the fish are further enhanced by the heat, which helps to caramelize and deepen all of the flavors within.

If you’re looking to add some pizzazz to your next meal without spending hours at the stovetop, look no further than a cast-iron skillet.

Cast irons can be used in almost any cooking appliance or under any heat source

You can fry a steak on your kitchen stovetop, bake a cake in the oven, and grill burgers on your outdoor grill—all using cast iron! Cast iron is very useful because it can hold up to very high temperatures without melting or warping.

Cast iron can be used on any heat source because it is a good heat conductor and keeps heat well. This makes it perfect for searing proteins in the oven.

Cast iron can be used on element heating stovetops, induction stovetops, ovens, inside a grill, and over an open fire.

Cast irons can stay hot for a long time

Cast-iron pans are heavy and thick and retain heat well. This means that cast iron pans can be used in any environment—on the stovetop, in an oven (either at home or over a campfire), or even outside.

If you’ve ever been to a restaurant where they cook their fish on cast iron, you know how many flavors it can add to your meal!

Cast iron pans are easy to clean and easy to maintain

Cleaning cast iron pans can be a bit of a challenge. Unlike other types of pans, cast iron requires some elbow grease when it comes to getting them clean. But once you’ve got the hang of it, you’ll wonder why you ever thought them difficult to clean.

For best results, wash your cast iron pan in hot water with mild soap and dry immediately after washing (soapy water will remain on the surface for long periods unless removed).

To keep your pan from rusting, wipe off any extra water with a paper towel or cloth before you dry it. If there’s any food left behind that needs more than just needs more cleaning, hot soapy water will do.

You can also use coarse salt and cold water instead. The coarse texture of the salt will break up stuck bits without damaging your pan’s seasoning layer!

What are the disadvantages of cooking fish on cast iron?

There are a few disadvantages to cooking your fish in a cast-iron skillet.

The first is that with a cast iron skillet, it may be harder to keep the fish from sticking.

With a cast iron skillet, you do have to be very careful about the fish, and you do have to make sure that you are not flipping it too soon and that you are being careful about flipping it.

Another issue is that with cast iron, you may also get a bit of flavor transfer from the cast iron, which may not be what you want for a fish fillet.

What type of fish should you cook on a cast-iron skillet?

1. Catfish

Catfish is considered a good choice for cooking on a cast-iron skillet because it is easy to grill and does not stick to the pan.

Additionally, catfish has low calories and high protein content, making it a healthy option.

Herbs and spices are also used in a lot of tasty recipes because they add flavor.

2. Salmon

Cooking salmon on a cast-iron skillet has several benefits, including that it results in a more crispy texture.

It also helps the skin of the salmon become crispy while keeping the center soft.

Furthermore, cast-iron skillets can be used to cook other meats, such as chicken and beef. The use of fresh herbs and lemon can further enhance the flavor of cooked fish when cooked in a cast iron skillet, creating an enjoyable meal.

3. Crappie

Crappie is a good type of fish to cook on a cast-iron skillet because it cooks quickly, in under 30 minutes, and the skillet can retain moisture for tender, moist fish with a crispy outer layer.

Cast iron cookware can also reach and stay at high temperatures, which makes it perfect for cooking fish.

4. Trout

Cooking trout on a cast-iron skillet has many benefits. Cast-iron skillets can retain heat, which is perfect for cooking trout.

The Lodge cast-iron skillet is the most popular choice and an ideal size for cooking one or two servings of trout. Additionally, the nonstick surface makes cleanup easy after cooking the fish.

Also, if you serve it with baby potatoes, you can make a flavorful and protein-packed meal.

5. Tuna

Cooking tuna on a cast-iron skillet provides many benefits, such as the ability to get a crispy crust on the fish.

Also, this way of cooking tuna gives you a lot of protein and few carbs if you season it before putting it in the skillet.

The dish can even be completed with cherry tomatoes and spinach for a complete meal.

6. Marlin

Cooking marlin on a cast-iron skillet has numerous advantages. It is easy to clean, and the fish comes out moist and flavorful.

Additionally, cast-iron skillets are durable and can last for many years, making them a good investment.

Cooking marlin in a cast-iron skillet also allows for perfect grilling or baking of the fish, as well as its ideal size for whole fish.

7. Tilapia

Cooking tilapia on a cast-iron skillet has many benefits. It is an inexpensive and mild-flavored fish that can be cooked easily using this method.

Grilling it on the grate is also possible, but wrapping it in foil is recommended to prevent the fish from breaking apart.

The cast-iron skillet helps retain moisture and ensures even cooking for an optimal result.

8. Halibut

Cooking halibut on a cast-iron skillet has many benefits. The fish will cook evenly, and the resulting presentation is enhanced with the addition of fresh lemon slices and herbs.

The texture of the fish will be crispy due to cooking it on a cast-iron skillet, as well as having a nice flavor.

Butter, ghee, coconut oil, or olive oil are all good options for cooking fish on a cast-iron skillet.

Adding salt and lemon slices before serving makes it even more flavorful, and tartar sauce can also be added to top off the dish.

9. Grouper

Cooking grouper on a cast-iron skillet has many benefits. The pan spreads the heat out evenly and helps seal in the fish’s flavors.

Also, fish cooked in cast-iron cookware takes on its flavor, giving it a unique and delicious taste.

So, cooking grouper in a cast-iron skillet is quick and easy; it can be served with fresh lemon wedges and sauteed veggies or rice for an enjoyable meal in minutes.

10. Drum

The drum is a good type of fish to cook on a cast-iron skillet because it is high in omega-3 fatty acids, making it a healthier option for cooking.

Additionally, the dish takes little time to prepare and can be made more flavorful with the addition of low-fat cream.

The cast iron retains heat well, which helps ensure even cooking and helps start fires easily due to its chimney starter feature.

11. Cod

Cod can be cooked in a cast-iron skillet, which has many benefits, including a steady, even heat.

The surface of a skillet provides an excellent cooking surface that helps create flavorful and juicy cod dishes.

Additionally, a variety of seasonings can be used to add flavor to cod cooked in a cast-iron skillet, such as flour, breadcrumbs, and fresh herbs like dill for a more sophisticated flavor.

12. Barramundi

Barramundi is an ideal choice for cooking on a cast-iron skillet because it is thin and has a high heat tolerance, making it easy to cook without burning.

Additionally, barramundi holds seasoning well, and its mild flavor does not overpower other flavors in the dish.

It is also low in fat and easy to clean, leaving no residue or spots on the pan.

What tips do you need to consider when cooking fish on a cast iron?

1. Avoid cooking acidic foods in cast-iron pans

Acidic foods shouldn’t be cooked in cast-iron pans because the metals in the pan could get into the food and give it a metallic taste.

For this reason, you should avoid cooking with tomato sauce, lemons, and wine for more than 30 minutes at a time to prevent them from eating into the iron.

Finally, it is important to remember that cast iron needs to be properly cared for to maintain its quality and avoid rusting.

2. Be aware that a cast-iron surface takes on flavors

People need to know that a cast-iron surface can take on flavors because leaving food in the pan for a long time can break down the seasoning and give the food a metallic taste.

Additionally, if the cast iron has not been properly seasoned before use, it may also contribute an unpleasant taste to delicate foods like fish.

It is important to season your cast-iron pan well and avoid leaving or storing food in it.

3. Don’t cook delicate fish in cast iron

It is important not to cook delicate fish in cast iron because the surface of the skillet can be too rough and cause sticking.

Also, cast iron needs to be well seasoned before it can be used, and it needs to be kept dry to avoid rust and loss of seasoning.

If a cast iron pan is wet or acidic, it can easily become damaged.

Sticking is less likely to happen if you heat the pan on medium heat first and add oil or butter before cooking.

You should also add oil to the fish to double up on that non-stick property.

4. Before your skillet is well-seasoned, avoid sticky foods

A well-seasoned cast iron skillet is important for reducing the risk of sticking and making cooking easier.

I recommend you season your cast iron with at least three layers of oil but no more than five.

If you want to prevent food from sticking, then you should spread a light coating of oil on the fish as well.

5. Avoid storing food in your cast-iron pan

Putting food in a cast-iron pan is not a good idea because it can cause the pan to rust and give the food a metallic taste.

Also, if you leave food in a cast-iron skillet for a long time, it can give off toxins that could be bad for your health.

If your cast iron is not seasoned and you still store food in it, you can be causing food to seep down into the crevices of your cast iron surface. Food can get stuck in here, and it will be hard to clean.

It is important to avoid storing food in a cast-iron pan, as this could lead to potential food poisoning and other health hazards.

6. Pan-sear fish in a cast-iron skillet to achieve a crispy outer crust

Using a cast iron pan to sear fish has many advantages over other ways to cook fish.

The use of seasoned cast iron cookware helps prevent the fish from sticking, as well as making it easier to flip and take off the grill.

Also, when cooking fish in a cast iron skillet, you should use a medium-high heat setting, and patience is the key to getting the results you want.

This method also results in an appealing brown crust, ensuring that your dish looks as good as it tastes!

Lastly, two forks can be used to test for doneness, with fully cooked flakes indicating that your dish is ready for consumption.

What are some common mistakes people make when cooking fish on cast iron?

Some common mistakes that people make when cooking fish in cast iron are:

They do remove the skin. If your fish has skin on it, you should leave it intact. It can help with cooking and it can also help with flavor.
Another issue is that they do not dry the fish off. This can cause burning and it can also cause the fish to stick.
You may also be tempted to not use any butter for basting, you want to baste the fish to keep it from drying out.
They try to move it around too much. You want to leave the fish completely still until just before you flip it. This is going to keep it from sticking and from breaking up.

How to prevent fish from sticking to your cast iron

There are a few ways to prevent your fish from sticking to the pan. The first is to choose the right kind of fish.

You want a firm fish that has the skin if you can find it, and you want to make sure you are placing the fish skin down in the pan.

You also want to make sure you let it cook long enough before you flip it.

You must be basting the fish as well to help keep the second side from sticking and to prevent the fish from drying out.

You want a fillet that is thick enough that it is not going to break up when you try to cook it.

How do you clean a cast iron pan that has fish stuck to it?

A pan that has fish stuck in it can be annoying. Cleaning a cast iron pan with fish stuck in it is not difficult if you know what you’re doing.

Let your pan cool fully. This is important and you do need to let the pan cool entirely before you try to handle it in any way.
Next, remove any large pieces that you can get off easily.
Lightly scrape the bottom of the pan to remove any pieces that are not stuck on too hard so that you can move to the next step.
You then need to put the pan in the sink and allow it to soak for a few minutes. This will help to loosen up the stuck-on pieces so that you can then start removing them.
After soaking, use a spatula to see if you can scrape any more off of the pan.
Then, using warm soapy water, wash the pan as well as you can, and then you can start scrubbing.
When scrubbing, you can use something called cast iron mail which is a piece of chain mail that is used to help scrub the pans, or you can use a scouring pad to scrub.
If you have to scrub very hard, you may end up needing to re-season your pan after you have gotten done scrubbing. Cast iron is very resilient, so you can scrub pretty hard.

Other interesting articles: